Who is Chaïm Perelman?

Born in Warsaw in 1912, Chaïm Perelman emigrated to Belgium in 1925 and acquired Belgian nationality in 1936. After completing his secondary education, at a time when rhetoric was still taught in schools, he enrolled at the Université libre de Bruxelles. He obtained doctorates in law and philosophy in 1934 and 1938 respectively. His early publications attest to the importance of his ties to the Université libre de Bruxelles. As early as the 1930s, he acknowledged his debt to his “teachers”, foremost among them Eugène Dupréel, but also Marcel Barzin (“De l’arbitraire dans la connaissance”, Archives de la société belge de philosophie, fasc. 3, 1933, pp. 10–11). Barzin supervised his doctoral thesis in philosophy, entitled Étude sur Frege (1938).

Fela and Chaïm Perelman papers (2006.432), United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, Washington, DC, USA.

Forced to relinquish his teaching duties in 1940, Chaïm Perelman joined the “civil resistance” alongside his wife, Fela Perelman. They became involved in the Comité de défense des Juifs, formed at a meeting held at their home on rue de la Pêcherie. This resistance movement helped save thousands of Jewish children (Lucien Steinberg, Le Comité de défense des juifs en Belgique, Éditions de l’Université de Bruxelles, 1973).

His return to academic work was marked by the publication in 1945 of a substantial study entitled “De la justice” (republished in Justice et raison, Presses Universitaires de Bruxelles, 1963). This seminal work was revisited in 1966 in “Cinq leçons sur la justice” (republished in Droit, morale et philosophie, L.G.D.J., 1968). There, a passage resembling a manifesto reveals a guiding thread in his philosophical endeavour:

“Exactly twenty years have passed since I finished writing my first study on justice. Yet, rather than consider my task complete and turn to other work, I have never ceased to reflect on this notion.”

Translated from the French for this page.

The importance of the legal paradigm in Perelman’s work should not, however, obscure his engagement with a scholarly community extending beyond the philosophy of law. Readers of Dialectica (Revue Internationale de Philosophie des Sciences) would have recognised rue de la Pêcherie, by then thankfully freed from the tragic years of the Second World War, as the address at which to contact the author. From 1947 to 1964, he was tireless in contributing to the epistemological debates surrounding the development of an “open philosophy” of knowledge, or idonéisme. His dialogue with Ferdinand Gonseth, among others, reminds us of the decisive importance Perelman attached to the situated and revisable character of all knowledge (“Philosophies premières et philosophie régressive”, Dialectica, no. 11, 1949).

Life and work