A More Suitable Brussels Housing Code for People in Vulnerable Situations: A Victory for the Equality Law Clinic

November 2025
Prof. Isabelle Rorive and Zoé Vandenberg, Equality Law Clinic, Centre Perelman, Faculty of Law and Criminology, Université libre de Bruxelles (ULB).
This blog post was written as part of the PCI Programme (Promotion of Citizenship and Interculturality) of the French Community of Belgium. We thank Amanda Garcia Cano for her careful proofreading.
On Thursday 9 October 2025, the Belgian Constitutional Court upheld the validity of the Brussels-Capital Region Ordinance of 22 June 2023. The Ordinance amended the Brussels Housing Code by introducing new procedural rules for judicial evictions, with a view to bringing them into line with the right to adequate housing enshrined in the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR).
This legislative development followed the findings adopted on 12 October 2021 in Lorne Walters v. Belgium by the UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (CESCR). Explicitly relying on the Equality Law Clinic’s documented third-party intervention (§§ 6.1–6.6), the Committee, which monitors the implementation of the Covenant, held that the rigidity of the Brussels legal framework was incompatible with the right to adequate housing. In particular, that framework neither allowed the disproportionate impact of evictions on vulnerable groups to be taken into account nor provided them with alternative rehousing solutions to mitigate those effects (§ 12.1).
In this case, the Equality Law Clinic played a decisive role in demonstrating that the eviction procedure disproportionately and discriminatorily interfered with the right to housing. In a context in which nearly eleven eviction judgments are handed down every day in the Brussels-Capital Region, this blog revisits the details of the case and the legislative developments that followed it.
The facts of the Lorne Walters case
Mr Lorne Walters, who submitted the communication to the CESCR, was 73 years old at the time. He lived alone and had no source of income other than a social benefit: the Income Guarantee for Older People (GRAPA). On 21 August 2017, his landlord informed him that she was unilaterally terminating his tenancy without giving any reason. Mr Walters had always paid his rent on time and complied with the terms of his lease. Article 237(4) of the Brussels Housing Code, which reproduced the provision in the federal Act of 20 February 1991 on residential leases, permits a landlord to terminate a lease unilaterally without cause after three or six years, subject to six months’ notice and payment of compensation. Mr Walters therefore had to leave by 28 February 2018, although he had lived in the apartment for 24 years. The landlord’s decision was upheld by the court of first instance, which nevertheless granted Mr Walters a grace period of several months. The eviction was initially postponed because of mental health problems directly related to the events, but ultimately took place in October 2018.
Faced with a shortage of social housing, and unable to find an apartment on the private market, Mr Walters was left homeless. The Public Centre for Social Welfare (CPAS) could offer him only transitional accommodation or a place in a care home for older people. The landlord, meanwhile, re-let the apartment for €900 per month, a 71.4% increase on the original rent of €525. This case is representative of the gentrification under way in the Brussels-Capital Region. As the Brussels Housing Rights Coalition has pointed out, “affordable housing is becoming increasingly scarce, and in some cases is virtually non-existent for low-income families”. Rents in Brussels rose by nearly 20% between 2010 and 2020, and the average rent in the city exceeded €1,100 for the first time in 2022.
The Equality Law Clinic’s third-party intervention
In its third-party intervention, the Equality Law Clinic (ELC) documented the disproportionate and discriminatory interference with Mr Walters’s right to adequate housing.
The ELC first recalled that Article 11 of the ICESCR guarantees everyone legal protection against eviction. This protection applies to both public and private rented housing and enables tenants to enjoy their right to housing, including when a lease expires. Eviction is therefore, in principle, contrary to the right to adequate housing and may be ordered only exceptionally and on justified grounds. To be proportionate, an eviction must be adequately justified, constitute a measure of last resort and be subject to an effective remedy.
The ELC argued that the very possibility of terminating a lease without cause and evicting a tenant from their home “conflicts with the requirement to give reasons”. This legal arrangement creates a significant imbalance between the protection of an owner’s right to dispose freely of their property and the right to housing. The ELC also showed that, in practice, unilateral termination without cause is predominantly used to increase rent substantially. Moreover, as the CESCR also observed, termination without cause is exceptional in legal systems comparable to Belgium’s. Germany, Switzerland and France, for example, provide tenants with greater legal protection.
The ELC further demonstrated that evictions without alternative rehousing, when ordered against vulnerable people, may amount to indirect intersectional discrimination. It stressed that “the actual impact of terminating a lease without cause is particularly harmful and disproportionate for tenants belonging to vulnerable groups”. More specifically, it showed how Mr Walters’s age and socio-economic circumstances interacted to make him vulnerable to eviction. Evictions mainly affect people in precarious and vulnerable situations, and their consequences are more severe for them than for other groups of tenants. In fact, in 2018 the proportion of people forced to leave their homes was highest among pensioners, at 27%. These tenants are also unable to find alternative accommodation because of their low incomes and the socio-economic conditions in Brussels. Older people also face prejudice from landlords, who are often more reluctant to enter into tenancy agreements with them.
The ELC also highlighted the serious effects on physical and mental health that make older tenants particularly vulnerable to eviction. Evictions may lead to increased disorientation, mental health crises or stress, especially for people who depend more heavily on their local social networks. In this case, Mr Walters’s psychiatrist had attested to the risk that he would be cut off from that network.
The CESCR’s decision
In its decision of 23 November 2021, the CESCR fully considered the ELC’s arguments.
The Committee first confirmed that evictions are, in principle, contrary to the right to housing and must in any event comply with the principle of proportionality (§§ 9.2–9.3). States are required to take all reasonable measures to provide alternative housing for people left homeless following an eviction (§ 10.1). Such measures must take account of the needs of the person evicted and the urgency of their situation (§ 10.2). They must also ensure access to “adequate housing”, which the Committee defines by reference to a range of criteria: “legal security of tenure; the availability of services, materials, facilities and infrastructure; affordability; habitability; accessibility; location, which must allow access to social services (education, employment and health services); and respect for the cultural environment, so as to permit the expression of cultural identity and diversity” (§ 10.3).
The Committee then held that unilateral termination without cause could, in the abstract, be compatible with the right to adequate housing in light of the safeguards available to tenants: six months’ notice, compensation, limits on when termination may be exercised, and the possibility of asking a court to postpone an eviction. For the Committee, however, this abstract assessment was not enough. It had to be supplemented by an assessment of the specific circumstances, which the Committee carried out with the support of the ELC’s third-party intervention. It found that the rigid application of this legal framework in the Brussels context could have disproportionate effects on vulnerable groups—in this case, older people with low incomes (§ 12.2), who face growing difficulties in finding new accommodation in the urban rental market (§ 12.7). The State is therefore required to take all necessary measures to mitigate the impact of unilateral termination without cause on vulnerable people.
On that basis, the Committee considered the rehousing solutions offered to Mr Walters, who had been left homeless, inadequate. The consequences of his eviction were indeed disproportionate and amounted to a violation of the right to adequate housing, both on its own and in conjunction with the right to non-discrimination under Article 2 of the Covenant (§ 12.8).
Legislative developments
In response to the CESCR’s decision, the Brussels Parliament adopted an Ordinance in June 2023 amending the procedures applicable to evictions. The explanatory memorandum expressly refers to the need to improve the procedural rules governing evictions so as to ensure that “they are compatible with the Covenant and with the general principles requiring all measures taken to be reasonable and proportionate in view of the legitimate aim of the eviction and its consequences for the persons concerned”.
The Brussels Ordinance introduced several measures, the most significant of which reorganise proceedings in tenancy disputes to ensure that the Public Centre for Social Welfare (CPAS) can intervene more effectively. It requires a formal notice to be served before any court action is brought. The time allowed before a hearing is extended so that the CPAS can conduct a social inquiry before the initial hearing. These measures help ensure that an eviction is ordered only as a last resort and that, where necessary, every effort is made to find a sustainable rehousing solution.
The Ordinance also establishes a winter moratorium, which it describes as “an automatic solution to a structural problem”. Evictions are prohibited from 1 November to 15 March, subject to strictly defined exceptions. The landlord is entitled to an occupancy allowance and may call on the solidarity fund if the tenant defaults. The winter pause is intended to prevent an eviction from creating “an inhuman situation where no rehousing solution is available during a period of acute danger”.
Finally, the Ordinance provides for evictions to be monitored under the auspices of the Housing Observatory. This is a measure advocated by the CESCR. Given the disproportionate consequences that termination without cause combined with eviction proceedings may have for certain groups, the Committee requires States parties to “establish a mechanism to monitor the impact of the application of the legal framework on the most vulnerable and marginalised groups, in order to make the necessary adjustments” (§ 12.3).
Conclusion
The Lorne Walters case and the legislative amendments that followed it demonstrate the role played by the Equality Law Clinic’s third-party intervention. By providing decisive contextual and legal analysis, the Clinic helped document the case brought before the CESCR, which led to a finding against Belgium and subsequently to an amendment of the Brussels Housing Code.
The case illustrates the strength of the normative dialogue between international human rights protection mechanisms, civil society actors and the legislature. It shows how legal mobilisation can serve as a practical lever for transforming the law and making social rights effective.
However, although Mr Walters prevailed and the Brussels Housing Code was amended, the case did not change the legal mechanism at its heart: a landlord’s ability to terminate a tenancy unilaterally without cause, subject to notice and compensation. In the Brussels-Capital Region, this option continues to undermine the right to housing. The Lorne Walters case therefore marks a legal victory, but a partial one; above all, it reminds us that ensuring the full effectiveness of the right to adequate housing remains a goal yet to be achieved for many people in vulnerable situations.

