Abstract :
While the right to abortion is not spelled out as such in the international or regional human rights treaties, recent developments strongly support the view that a right to safe and legal abortion is a woman’s human right. A sustainable model of conscientious objection in reproductive healthcare must take into account the human rights developments concerning induced abortion. For the past hundred years, conscientious objection has been used almost exclusively in the context of refusal to perform compulsory military service. There are major difficulties in trying to transpose the debate surrounding conscientious objection to the realm of reproductive health. The wider context of conscience claims raised after the legalisation of same-sex unions is even more disturbing. It shows the detrimental effect that accommodation policies could have on the full operation of non-discrimination law.
Recent supranational and national cases show that the recognition of conscientious objection in reproductive healthcare is hardly sustainable on the ground. A snowball effect seems inevitable. And even well-defined legal safeguards are failing. This leads to wide discriminatory treatment based on gender, territorial status, low social condition and ethnicity. This also leads to the failure to recognise the dignitary harm to women and the perpetuation of social prejudice and structural inequality which result from this approach. In other words, designing, implementing and monitoring a strictly regulated conscience clause in reproductive healthcare resembles an effort to square the circle. Something always falls by the wayside, and the ‘something’ is no less than women’s human rights.
Accueil >
Conscientious objection in reproductive healthcare
![arton2154-039e8.jpg](https://centreperelman.be//content/uploads/2022/08/arton2154-039e8-100x142.jpg)
Publications récentes
-
La valeur fondamentale de l’égalité des genres comme motif de protection internationale – analyse…
Par Hania Ouhnaoui, assistante chargée d’exercices pour l’Equality Law Clinic et Sarah Bertholet, stagiaire pour l’Equality Law Clinic[1]. Le 11 juin… -
Obligations positives face aux violences sexuelles et sexistes
Isabelle Rorive a contribué au premier numéro d’Intersections. Revue semestrielle Genre& Droit. Elle a participé à la chronique « Discriminations, Inégalités… -
L’affaire Caster Semenya
Le 26 juin, Isabelle Rorive était l’invitée d’Antoine Garapon dans l’émission « Esprit de justice » de France Culture pour discuter de… -
Portrait de Chaïm Perelman par Benoit Frydman
L’Association Internationale de Méthodologie Juridique (AIMJ) publie un portrait de Chaïm Perelman par Benoit Frydman https://aimj.ca/portraits-de-chercheurs/…